Calgary’s long, harsh winters put older boiler systems under constant stress. When breakdowns start happening more often, homeowners face a tough question: repair the boiler again or replace it entirely. Understanding costs, risks, and long-term value helps you make the right decision for your home.
Need a New Boiler?
With Flexible Financing Options
How Old Is “Too Old” for a Boiler in Calgary?
Boiler age alone doesn’t determine whether repairs are worthwhile, but it’s a critical factor when combined with performance and repair history. Calgary’s climate places heavier demands on heating systems than milder regions.
Average Boiler Lifespan in Calgary Homes
Most traditional non-condensing boilers last about 15–20 years, while modern condensing boilers can reach 20–25 years with proper maintenance. Hard water, long run times, and frequent cycling during winter can shorten these ranges.
Why Calgary Winters Accelerate Boiler Wear
Extended cold snaps force boilers to operate continuously, increasing pressure on heat exchangers, pumps, and controls. Freeze-thaw cycles and dry air also raise the risk of leaks, pressure loss, and component failure.
When Repairing an Old Boiler Still Makes Sense
Not every aging boiler needs immediate replacement. In some situations, repairs remain practical and cost-effective.
1. Minor or Isolated Component Failures
Issues like faulty sensors, pressure relief valves, or ignition components are often affordable to fix and don’t indicate full system failure. These repairs can safely extend boiler life when the core system is still sound.
2. Boiler Still Operating Efficiently
If the boiler maintains steady pressure, heats evenly, and hasn’t required frequent service, repairs may be justified. Efficiency and reliability matter more than age alone.
3. Short-Term Ownership or Budget Constraints
If you plan to sell soon or need a temporary solution before renovations, repairing may be the logical short-term choice. In these cases, professional boiler repair in Calgary helps ensure safe operation.
Signs It’s No Longer Worth Repairing an Old Boiler
Some warning signs indicate repairs are becoming a money pit rather than a solution.
Frequent Breakdowns or Emergency Calls
Repeated service calls, especially during winter, signal declining reliability. Emergency repairs often cost more and increase the risk of total system failure in extreme cold.
Repair Costs Approaching Replacement Value
When cumulative repairs approach 50% of the cost of a new boiler, replacement usually offers better long-term value and peace of mind.
Rising Heating Bills and Poor Performance
Older boilers lose efficiency over time. If heating bills climb despite repairs, the system may no longer convert fuel efficiently.
Safety or Code Compliance Concerns
Corrosion, venting issues, or outdated safety controls increase risks. These warning signs your boiler needs repair often justify replacement over continued fixes.
Boiler Repair Costs in Calgary (2026 Estimates)
Repair pricing depends on the issue, accessibility, and whether service is required during peak winter demand.
Repair Type | Typical Cost Range (CAD) |
Minor system bleeding or adjustments | $100–$200 |
Pressure relief valve replacement | $150–$350 |
Expansion tank repair or replacement | $300–$600 |
Leak repair in pipes or radiators | $200–$1,000+ |
Full system inspection and maintenance | $500–$1,000 |
Emergency winter service can increase costs due to after-hours labour and parts availability.
Boiler Replacement Costs in Calgary
Replacing an aging boiler is a larger investment, but it often delivers better efficiency and reliability.
Average Boiler Replacement Cost
Most boiler replacements in Calgary range from $6,000 to $12,000+, depending on efficiency level, home size, and system complexity.
Factors That Increase Replacement Cost
Homes with radiant floor heating, multiple zones, venting upgrades, or electrical and gas modifications typically fall at the higher end. Professional boiler replacement in Calgary ensures correct sizing and code compliance.
Repair vs Replace: A Practical Calgary Decision Guide
Choosing between repair and replacement depends on long-term value, not just today’s invoice.
Repair Is Smarter If…
The boiler has infrequent issues, repair costs are low, and the system still operates efficiently without safety concerns.
Replacement Is Smarter If…
Breakdowns are frequent, repair costs keep rising, or efficiency has dropped significantly. In Calgary’s climate, reliability often outweighs short-term savings.
Long-Term Cost Considerations
High-efficiency boilers reduce fuel usage, require fewer repairs, and provide more consistent comfort during extreme cold, often offsetting the higher upfront cost.
Why Comfort Union Recommends an Inspection Before Deciding
A professional assessment removes guesswork and prevents costly mistakes.
What a Professional Boiler Inspection Includes
Technicians evaluate the heat exchanger, pressure levels, expansion tank, venting, efficiency, and safety controls to determine true system health.
Avoiding Costly Winter Surprises
Scheduling boiler maintenance in Calgary before failure helps homeowners plan upgrades instead of reacting to emergencies.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is it worth repairing a 20-year-old boiler in Calgary?
It depends on condition and cost. If repairs are minor and the heat exchanger is intact, repair may work short-term. Frequent issues or high costs usually mean replacement is safer.
How long can I keep repairing an old boiler?
As long as safety isn’t compromised and repairs remain affordable. However, reliability drops sharply after 20 years, especially in Calgary winters.
Are emergency boiler repairs more expensive in winter?
Yes. After-hours labour, urgent parts sourcing, and peak demand often increase winter repair costs.
Can a new boiler lower heating bills?
Yes. Modern high-efficiency boilers use less gas and provide more consistent heat compared to older systems.
High-efficiency furnaces installed by licensed Calgary techs. Built for cold winters, backed by strong warranties. Perfect for families upgrading for comfort and savings.
One smart system for home heat and hot water. Our Calgary team installs Navien and IBC combi boilers with expert care, space-saving design, and energy efficiency.
Losing heat or hot water? We diagnose and fix combi boiler issues fast with honest pricing, licensed repairs, and no surprise fees.
