Choosing between Goodman and Carrier furnaces is a major decision for Calgary homeowners who rely on dependable heat for much of the year. Both brands are widely installed across Alberta, but they differ in pricing, efficiency options, and long-term ownership experience.
Understanding how these furnaces perform in Calgary’s climate helps homeowners choose a system that balances comfort, energy savings, and repair costs over time.
Need a New Furnace?
With Flexible Financing Options
Why Comparing Goodman and Carrier Matters for Calgary Homes
Calgary experiences long heating seasons, frequent freeze-thaw cycles, and extended cold snaps that push furnaces harder than in milder regions. Comparing Goodman and Carrier helps homeowners understand how efficiency, durability, and serviceability affect real-world performance in local conditions.
Both brands offer high-efficiency gas furnaces, but differences in design philosophy and parts availability can influence long-term satisfaction.
Goodman Furnaces for Calgary Homeowners
Goodman furnaces are popular in Calgary for their affordability, simple design, and strong performance when installed correctly. Many homeowners choose Goodman for dependable heating without premium pricing.
Goodman systems are commonly found in single-family homes, rental properties, and budget-conscious upgrades throughout the city.
Goodman Furnace Technology and Efficiency
Goodman offers gas furnaces with AFUE ratings up to 98%, including single-stage, two-stage, and modulating options. Many models feature variable-speed ECM blowers that improve airflow consistency and reduce energy consumption during Calgary’s extended heating season.
Their straightforward design prioritizes reliability and ease of service, which appeals to homeowners focused on long-term maintenance costs.
Popular Goodman Furnace Models in Calgary
Goodman GM9S80
This single-stage furnace is a dependable entry-level option for Calgary homes needing reliable heat without advanced modulation. It delivers consistent performance and simple operation.
Key Features:
- 80% AFUE rating
- Durable aluminized steel heat exchanger
- Straightforward controls
Ideal For
Homeowners seeking an affordable replacement furnace for smaller homes or rental properties.
Goodman GMEC96
The GMEC96 adds higher efficiency and improved comfort control through a two-stage gas valve and variable-speed blower. It balances performance and value well for Alberta climates.
Key Features:
- Up to 96% AFUE efficiency
- Quieter operation
- Improved temperature consistency.
Ideal For
Mid-sized Calgary homes focused on energy savings without premium pricing.
Goodman GMVM97
This modulating furnace delivers near-continuous low-output heating, ideal for maintaining even comfort during long cold stretches.
Key Features:
- Up to 97% AFUE efficiency
- Modulating gas valve
- Advanced airflow control
Ideal For
Larger homes or homeowners prioritizing comfort and efficiency while keeping costs lower than premium brands.
Goodman Furnace Cost and Repair Costs in Calgary
Installed Goodman furnace costs in Calgary typically range from $4,500 to $7,500, depending on efficiency level, home size, and ductwork condition. Repair costs usually fall between $200 and $600, with parts widely available through local suppliers.
Homeowners planning a replacement can review our Furnace Installation Calgary service for professional installation options.
Carrier Furnaces for Calgary Homeowners
Carrier furnaces are widely known for advanced technology, quiet operation, and strong cold-weather reliability. Many Calgary homeowners choose Carrier when comfort control and long-term performance are top priorities.
Carrier systems are commonly installed in higher-end homes and properties with complex airflow needs.
Carrier Furnace Technology and Efficiency
Carrier offers high-efficiency gas furnaces with AFUE ratings up to 98.5%, featuring fully modulating burners and variable-speed blowers. These systems adjust output precisely, reducing temperature swings and lowering gas consumption during Calgary’s long winters.
Carrier furnaces also integrate well with hybrid and dual-fuel systems for homeowners planning future upgrades.
Popular Carrier Furnace Models in Calgary
Carrier Comfort 80
This entry-level model provides consistent heating with straightforward operation and solid reliability.
Key Features:
- 80% AFUE rating
- Single-stage operation
- Durable construction
Ideal For
Smaller Calgary homes or budget-focused replacements where simplicity is preferred.
Carrier Performance 96
The Performance 96 offers improved efficiency and quieter operation through two-stage heating and a variable-speed blower.
Key Features:
- Up to 96.7% AFUE
- Better humidity control
- Smoother temperature transitions
Ideal For
Mid-sized homes seeking efficiency upgrades without stepping into premium pricing.
Carrier Infinity 98
Carrier’s flagship furnace delivers top-tier efficiency and precise comfort control for demanding environments.
Key Features:
- Up to 98.5% AFUE
- Fully modulating gas valve
- Advanced system intelligence
Ideal For
Large Calgary homes prioritizing maximum comfort, quiet operation, and energy savings.
Carrier Furnace Cost and Repair Costs in Calgary
Carrier furnace installation in Calgary typically ranges from $5,000 to $9,500, depending on model and system complexity. Repair costs usually fall between $250 and $900, with excellent parts availability across the city.
For servicing and diagnostics, homeowners can explore Furnace Repair Calgary for local support.
Goodman vs Carrier Furnace Comparison for Calgary
Comparing Goodman and Carrier side by side highlights differences that matter most during Alberta winters. Performance, serviceability, and long-term costs often outweigh brand reputation alone.
Factors to Consider for Calgary Homes
Selecting the right furnace involves more than choosing a brand. Calgary homeowners should evaluate how installation quality, climate demands, and service costs affect long-term comfort and reliability.
These factors often have a greater impact than the furnace label itself.
1. Installation Quality
Proper sizing through professional heat load calculations ensures efficient operation and even heating. Oversized or undersized furnaces waste energy and increase breakdown risk during extreme cold.
2. Cold-Weather Performance
Calgary’s sub-zero temperatures demand reliable ignition and consistent airflow. Furnaces with variable-speed motors and staged heating perform better during prolonged cold snaps.
3. Repair and Maintenance Costs
Access to local parts and experienced technicians keeps long-term ownership costs predictable. Simpler designs often translate to faster, less expensive repairs.
Which Furnace Brand Is Better for Your Calgary Home?
Goodman is often the better choice for homeowners prioritizing affordability, straightforward maintenance, and solid cold-weather reliability. Carrier is ideal for those seeking premium comfort control, quieter operation, and advanced efficiency features.
The right option depends on budget, home size, comfort expectations, and how long you plan to stay in your home.
Cost to Replace or Repair a Furnace in Calgary
| Service Type | Typical Cost Range (Calgary) | What It Covers |
| Furnace Repair | $200 – $900 | Igniters, blower motors, control boards, sensors, minor gas valve issues |
| Furnace Replacement | $4,500 – $9,500 | New furnace, installation labour, venting, setup, and system testing |
Gas Furnace vs Electric Furnace Options in Calgary
Gas furnaces remain the primary heating solution in Calgary due to extreme winter temperatures. Electric furnaces may suit smaller homes or supplemental heating, but gas systems provide better performance during prolonged cold.
Carrier explains these differences clearly in their guide on electric furnaces, helping homeowners understand when electric systems may be appropriate.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is Goodman or Carrier better for Calgary winters?
Both perform well in cold climates when installed properly. Carrier offers more advanced comfort features, while Goodman provides strong reliability at a lower upfront cost.
Which furnace brand is cheaper to repair in Calgary?
Goodman repairs are typically less expensive due to simpler designs and widely available parts. Carrier repairs can cost more on higher-end models.
How long do Goodman and Carrier furnaces last?
Most furnaces last 15–20 years with proper installation and maintenance. Regular servicing has a bigger impact than brand choice alone.
Does furnace brand matter more than installation quality?
No, installation quality matters more than brand. A properly sized and installed furnace will outperform a premium unit that is installed incorrectly.
Fast, reliable furnace repair in Calgary. We diagnose and fix all makes and models to restore your home’s warmth quickly and safely.
Keep your system running smoothly with a professional furnace tune-up in Calgary. We clean, inspect, and optimize for peak efficiency and safety.
Breathe easier with professional furnace duct cleaning in Calgary. Remove dust, debris, and allergens for cleaner air and better system performance.
